SPEN, Colo.,
March 30 — As another ski season winds down, industry officials in
Colorado are puzzling over why more people have died in skiing
accidents this winter than ever before, a record that has brought
new attention to the use of helmets for protection against serious
head injuries.
So far, the death toll in Colorado is 15 — 14 skiers and 1
snowboarder — surpassing the previous high of 12 set in the winter
of 1998-99. In only one case this season was the victim wearing a
helmet.
The accidents fall into no discernible pattern. Among the
victims, eight were male, seven were female. Their ages were 5 to
67, and their accidents occurred at nine resorts, where some were
skiing on expert slopes while others were on intermediate and easy
trails.
"Unfortunately, there was no common element," said Mike Kaplan,
vice president for mountain operations for the Aspen Skiing Company,
which runs four ski areas here where five of this season's deaths
occurred. "I almost wish there were. Then we could take more
decisive action."
Skiing accidents are not unlike car crashes. They can happen at
any time and often arise from a momentary lapse in judgment or an
irresponsible decision. Ski industry officials contend that the
number of deaths this year does not necessarily reflect any
dangerous new trends.
Annual fatality surveys by the National Ski Areas Association
show that in the 17 years of tracking, the total has fluctuated for
no apparent reason, with as many as 49 deaths in the 1994-95 season
and as few as 24 in 1989-90. Last season, 47 people died. The
association has not yet compiled a national number for the current
season.
But the skiing deaths in Colorado have recharged a debate over
the value of helmets, and no incident fueled arguments for their use
more than the death of Leonie Arguetty, 5, of Wellington, Fla., who
skied into a tree at Aspen Highlands during a private lesson in
February. Medical experts said she was one of several victims who
might have survived had they worn helmets.
Her death, one of four at Highlands this winter, prompted company
officials to require all children under 6 attending ski school to
wear helmets, a change that took effect last week.
Next season, all children under 12 must wear helmets, a
requirement that Vail Resorts is
also planning for next season. David Perry, chief executive of
Colorado Ski Country, a trade organization, said he expected other
resorts to follow.
It is a change that has been hailed by many medical officials,
who say helmets can reduce the severity of head injuries, which
account for as much as 90 percent of all skiing deaths. Mr. Kaplan
said the changes at the ski school were also designed to create
habits, so children would continue wearing helmets as they got older
and persuade their parents to start wearing them.
No major resort in North America requires adults to wear
helmets.
Industry experts, as well as emergency room doctors, warn that
helmets are no substitute for responsible behavior on the slopes and
that in the case of headstrong skiers, especially teenagers, they
may encourage foolish behavior by providing a false sense of
security.
Jasper E. Shealy, a retired professor of industrial engineering
at the Rochester Institute of Technology who has studied skiing
accidents for 30 years, said he worried that many skiers might
regard helmets as "a coat of armor" that might encourage them to
take chances.
He also cited studies that showed helmets were effective only up
to 12 miles an hour, a relatively slow speed for many skiers. "If
you're going 25 to 40 miles an hour," he said, "helmets are not
going to provide much protection."
But other ski injury experts disagreed, and some, like Dr. A.
Stewart Levy, a neurosurgeon in Denver, said that even at higher
speeds, helmets could reduce the seriousness of some head
injuries.
Dr. Steve Ayers, an emergency room physician in Aspen and the
Pitkin County coroner, said at least two of the victims at Aspen
Highlands — Robert Littlewood, 67, of Park City, Utah, and Tanja
Ehrmann, 26, of Germany, who were killed in accidents on expert
trails — might have survived had they been wearing helmets.
He said Mr. Littlewood fell, knocked himself out and slid down an
embankment before he was buried under the snow and died of
asphyxiation. Ms. Ehrmann, he said, fell and hit her head, knocking
herself out, and then bounced along a number of moguls that he
guessed caused the brain injuries that killed her.
Peggy Devan, coordinator of the ski school at Aspen Highlands, is
an advocate for helmets. It has become an easy sell, she said,
especially after the death of the Florida girl.
Waiting for her son Jack, 5, Judy Dolgin of Los Angeles, said she
had never worn a helmet skiing but would now strap one on if any of
her children asked. Her daughters, 11 and 9, are avid skiers and
helmet wearers.
But not all parents are convinced. Ms. Dolgin's friend Carrie
Adelson of Brentwood said it was proper for children like her
5-year-old son and daughter, Jeffrey and Lauren, who began skiing
three years ago.
"Better safe than sorry," she said, helping them out of their
equipment. "How could it possibly hurt?"
As for herself, she said, it was too late to change.
"Not me," she said. "I just can't do
it."